EFL CURRICULUM IN ECUADOR: THE
ACHIEVEMENT OF COMMUNICATIVE
COMPETENCES IN LEARNERS GRADUATED FROM
ECUADORIAN PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN MILAGRO
CURRÍCULO DE INGLÉS COMO LENGUA EXTRANJERA EN
ECUADOR: ALCANCE DE COMPETENCIAS
COMUNICATIVAS EN LOS BACHILLERES DE
INSTITUCIONES EDUCATIVAS PÚBLICAS EN MILAGRO
Ninfa Sofia Guevara-Peñaranda
Universidad Estatal de Milagro, Ecuador
Jorge Francisco Zambrano-Pachay
Universidad Estatal de Milagro, Ecuador
Paolo Geovanny Fabre Mérchan
Universidad Estatal de Milagro, Ecuador
pág. 6942
DOI: https://doi.org/10.37811/cl_rcm.v8i2.11100
EFL Curriculum in Ecuador: The Achievement of Communicative
Competences in Learners Graduated from Ecuadorian Public Schools in
Milagro
Ninfa Sofia Guevara Peñaranda1
nguevarap@unemi.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6638-8851
Universidad Estatal de Milagro
Ecuador
Jorge Francisco Zambrano Pachay
jzambranop10@unemi.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9456-2765
Universidad Estatal de Milagro
Ecuador
Paolo Geovanny Fabre Mérchan
pfabrem@unemi.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7457-0776
Universidad Estatal de Milagro
Ecuador
ABSTRACT
This research aims to test baccalaureate students’ oral communication production from public high
schools in the 2023 - 2024 academic year in Milagro city. A non-experimental research design was
applied in this study to determine the achievement of communication competences based on the second
thread from the Ecuadorian EFL curriculum. A questionnaire was elaborated to score listening
comprehension skills, and a checklist was used to evaluate oral production skills. Both data collection
instruments were applied and graded over 100 with the participation of 300 baccalaureate students from
fourteen public high schools, which means that this evaluation procedure allows us to have a
quantitative result based on the evaluation criteria and indicators from the National English Curriculum
Guidelines. The results were processed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS)
program to determine the media and a general average for our analysis and conclude if baccalaureate
students achieved a pre-intermediate-level proficiency (B1) in their oral communication production.
For this reason, this study wants to measure oral communication production and prove if the English
learning process has been achieved successfully according to the curricular objective of English as a
Foreign Language in Ecuador.
Keywords: curriculum, ecuadorian baccalaureate, oral communication, exit profile
1
Autor principal
Correspondencia: nguevarap@unemi.edu.ec
pág. 6943
Currículo de Inglés como Lengua Extranjera en Ecuador: Alcance de
Competencias Comunicativas en los Bachilleres de Instituciones Educativas
Públicas en Milagro
RESUMEN
Esta investigación tiene como objetivo probar la producción de la comunicación oral de los estudiantes
de bachillerato de los colegios públicos en el año académico 2023 - 2024 en la ciudad de Milagro. En
este estudio se aplicó un diseño de investigación no experimental para determinar el logro de las
competencias de comunicación basado en el segundo hilo del currículo EFL ecuatoriano. Se elaboró un
cuestionario para evaluar las habilidades de comprensión de la escucha y se utilizó una lista de
verificación para valorar las capacidades de producción oral. Ambos instrumentos de recopilación de
datos fueron aplicados y calificados a 100 con la participación de 300 estudiantes de bachillerato de
catorce escuelas secundarias públicas, lo que significa que este procedimiento de evaluación nos
permite tener un resultado cuantitativo basado en los criterios e indicadores de la Guía Nacional del
Currículo de Inglés. Los resultados se procesaron utilizando el Programa de Paquete Estadístico para
las Ciencias Sociales (SPSS) para determinar los medios y una media general para nuestro análisis y
concluir si los estudiantes de bachillerato alcanzaron un nivel pre-intermedio (B1) en su producción de
comunicación oral. Por esta razón, este estudio pretende medir la producción de comunicación oral y
demostrar si el proceso de aprendizaje del inglés se ha logrado con éxito de acuerdo con el objetivo
curricular del inglés como lengua extranjera en Ecuador.
Palabras claves: currículo, bachillerato ecuatoriano, comunicación oral, perfil de salida
Artículo recibido 20 marzo 2024
Aceptado para publicación: 25 abril 2024
pág. 6944
INTRODUCTION
Mastery of the English language is essential for achieving success in both academic and social domains.
Scholars such as Crystal (2003) and Warschauer (2005) have conducted extensive studies on the
significance of English as a medium that enables individuals to gain access to academic knowledge,
resources, and job opportunities on a global scale. Their studies have emphasized English’s role in
facilitating communication and fostering collaboration among individuals from diverse linguistic and
cultural backgrounds. Moreover, Guerrero-Quiñonez et al. (2023) point out that English has become
the lingua franca of international communication in business, education, technology, and entertainment.
Under these circumstances, in the educational field, acquiring solid English skills expands work and
academic opportunities and exposes them to other cultures and ways of thinking. English as a foreign
language enriches the human experience by facilitating communication and the exchange of ideas inside
and outside the classrooms.
Ecuador introduced a new National Curriculum in 2016, which contains an English as a Foreign
Language (EFL) curriculum divided into sublevels starting from Basic General Education to
Baccalaureate. Within the context of the Ecuadorian EFL curriculum, it is worth noting that learning
objectives occupy an important place in achieving a successful educational outcome. Performance
criteria skills are linked to evaluation criteria and indicators contributing to the Baccalaureate student's
exit profile. These carefully constructed goals form the foundation for desired learning outcomes for
students beginning to learn English as a foreign language (Lopez et al., 2021). By providing a roadmap
for students to follow, these goals provide teachers with a comprehensive roadmap, allowing them to
develop instructional strategies and assessment tools precisely designed to promote student success
(Alcaráz-Mármol, 2019).
The objectives of the English curriculum exit profile must align with students' needs and international
standards. Regular assessments are important to maintaining consistency between the curriculum and
learning objectives, which are informed by domain descriptions like the CEFR. In Ecuador, the EFL
curriculum, learning objectives, and assessment criteria are closely linked to create language learning
opportunities that can inspire transformation.
pág. 6945
The learning objectives in the Ecuadorian English as a Foreign Language curriculum serve as a guiding
star, illuminating the desired learning outcomes for students beginning to learn English as a foreign
language (Alvarez & Guevara, 2021). These carefully designed objectives are embedded within a
framework of educational goals and standards, reflecting the set of competencies and skills that students
are expected to acquire throughout their language-learning journey (Bernal & Bernal, 2020).
Teachers can effectively organize their instructional activities and assessment strategies by articulating
clear and measurable goals. This ensures that students are well-supported in pursuing these goals with
solid results (Romero-Romero et al., 2021). By carefully tailoring these goals to Ecuadorian English
learners' specific language proficiency levels and cultural nuances, educators can ensure that the
curriculum is appropriate, engages students, and leaves a lasting impact on them through various
linguistic elements (Villafuerte & Mosquera, 2020). Therefore, the structure to achieve the planned
objectives shows that high school students must reach level B1 according to the CEFR (Ministerio de
Educación, 2016).
The Ecuadorian EFL curriculum has five threads: Communication and cultural awareness, Oral
communication, Reading, Writing, and Language through the arts. This study focuses on the curricular
thread 2: Oral communication (listening and speaking) that provides a detailed understanding of the
pedagogical strategies and learning outcomes needed to develop language learners' effective
communication skills. Oral communication, including listening and speaking skills, is an essential
foundation of Ecuador's English curriculum, reflecting the importance of learning communicative and
interactive languages (Llerena & Van Ha, 2022).
This research wants to prove whether the communication competencies of learners who have graduated
from Ecuadorian Public Schools in Milagro are according to the EFL curriculum. The study intends to
determine students' English language proficiency and ability to communicate effectively in English.
The research will examine the learners' oral communication skills, including pronunciation, grammar,
fluency, and vocabulary usage. The findings of this study are expected to contribute significantly to
developing effective English language teaching strategies and materials for students in Ecuador's high
schools.
pág. 6946
METHODOLOGY
Study design
This study applied a non-experimental research design with the analysis of quantitative data. Campbell
and Stanley (2015) stated in their book that a non-experimental design is a method where the researchers
see and determine variables without manipulating them. This investigation is adapted to analyze the
nature of the phenomena and relationships without changing the variables. Also, our field of
investigation about oral communication in Ecuadorian EFL classrooms using quantitative data analysis
is aligned to determine our primary research question, which would be to understand the current state
of oral communication skills among recently graduated students belonging to the school year 2023 -
2024 from Milagro city and identify any factors influencing their proficiency through a test and
checklist as data collection instruments.
Population and sample
During our analysis to determine the effectiveness of the exit profile based on the second thread Oral
communication from the Ecuadorian EFL curriculum, baccalaureate students from public high schools
in Milagro city were selected by calculating the population and sample size. This process was
challenging, and it was hard to take a complete group of students from the different public schools. In
the final report from Educational Unit District Milagro (2023), nineteen public high schools, and
fourteen institutions participated in this research study. Moreover, around 3000 students graduated from
these public high schools, and our sample was selected randomly from a total of 300 students from the
fourteen public institutions. The participants were between the ages of 17 and 19 with a total of 140
male and 160 female students who were called to evaluate their oral communication skills through a
quantitative questionnaire.
Tools
The instruments and techniques were selected for our investigation question to measure the learners’
proficiency based on their oral communication skills. The techniques applied in the present study as the
primary source of quantitative data collection were a listening test and a checklist for speaking, used to
measure their language proficiency based on the skills with performance criteria from the Ecuadorian
EFL curriculum second thread. Yousef (2023) states in his article how beneficial it is to measure
pág. 6947
listening and speaking with correct data collection instruments. The test was developed using Google
Forms as a technological tool to collect the quantitative data required, and it contains three different
audios with questions focused on listening for meaning and specific information. In addition, the
checklist was elaborated based on the production, interaction, and fluency considering the CE.EFL.
5.7-8-9 from the evaluation criteria section. The test and the checklist were graded 100 out of 100. The
listening test contains ten questions, and each one grades 10 out of 10. On the other hand, the checklist
was developed with five indicators, each indicator grades from 2 to 10, taking into account the
components mentioned before.
RESULTS
According to the oral communication thread and its indicators for the performance criteria, graduate
students did not obtain a high score in their evaluations based on the communication competences
established in the Ecuadorian English Curriculum. This research evaluated some performance criteria
to measure oral communication production and listening for specific details. The quantitative data
collected were calculated by the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) program, and found
the following results:
For the present study, descriptive statistics have been used to characterize the study population. Taking
as reference the participation of 300 participants, this, in turn, is distributed as follows. In Figure 1,
53.33% were female, while 46.67% were male. Figure 2 shows the percentage of age of participation,
with age with the highest participation being the age of 17, corresponding to 61.67%, followed by those
who are 18, representing 34.00%, and the age with lower participation is 19, representing 4.33%.
Figure 1: Percentage according to gender
Source: Survey applied to the students.
pág. 6948
Figure 2: Percentage according to the age of the participants.
Source: Survey applied to the students.
Table 1 and Figure 3 show gender participation between the ages of 17, 18, and 19 years. The female
sex accounted for 53.33% of those aged 17 (117 people 39.00%), 18 years (38 people 12.67%) and
19 years (5 1.67%). In contrast, in the male sex, it represents 46.67%, where those who are 17 years
of age (68 people represent 22.67%), 18 years (64 people 21.33%) and those of 19 years (8 people
2.67%).
Table 1 Gender according to age and percentage of the sample.
Source: Test and Checklist instruments elaborated by the teachers
pág. 6949
Figure 3: Gender according to age and percentage of the sample.
Source: Gender according to age and percentage of the sample.
Table 2 compares the averages between the two gender tests where a one-factor ANOVA was applied,
which shows a small significant difference between the male and female genders in the application of
the Listening Test with a value of 069. Similarly, in the Speaking Test by gender, in this case, they did
not present a difference between groups with a value of 983.
Table 2: Listening Test and Speaking Test according to gender for the average
Figures 4 and 5 show the students’ comprehension and production by gender. Figure 4 determined that
graduate females obtained a low level of comprehension in the listening section, and it represented
27,31 %. They had some difficulties understanding the meaning and details of the audio applied.
However, male graduates achieved a 31,29 % understanding in the listening section, which is not
enough according to the Indicators for the performance criteria.
pág. 6950
Figure 5 represents the graduate students' oral production. Graduate males obtained 28,36 %, and
graduate females achieved 28,31 % over 100%. This result indicates that graduate students have a low
level of oral communication production.
Figure 4: Listening Test according to gender with respect to the average.
Figure 5: Speaking Test according to gender with respect to the average.
Table 3 presents the averages of both tests indicating Listening and Speaking skills. The data analysis
revealed that the average for male participants was 59.64, while for female participants, it was 55.62.
The average of both is 57, 5.
Table 3: Overall average of Listening and Speaking tests, by gender.
pág. 6951
DISCUSSION
The results of the current research confirm that there are some problems regarding the low level of
mastery in oral communication of students who belong to public high schools in Milagro City. Reasco
and Rodriguez (2022), in their study, have found the same way: the students, regarding students’ oral
production and comprehension of the English language, do not achieve the desired results based on the
national criteria, and they are in the process. This study was carried out in Milagro City, and graduate
students, after six years of being in EFL classrooms in different public high schools, need to improve
their language skills. Students require more interactive communication activities with authentic learning
to foster their interests when they have to produce their English inside the classroom.
According to the research done by Tawil (2018), language teachers should apply some techniques to
impart communicative skills more effectively to their learners. Moreover, The application of
contemporary topics, dynamic physical and digital resources, and high motivation are more
fundamental factors in this new way of teaching in contrast to traditional methods. Students may achieve
and retain more information, and their comprehensible input (Krashen,1982). is more effective and
promotes a successful learning environment.
As a result, our current Ecuadorian graduate students have not achieved the curricular objective of
English as a Foreign Language. Students need to develop their oral production, which means, accuracy
and intelligibility as components to have a clear speech. Also, interaction and fluency are other factors
to be considered at the time to communicate with someone else. From our findings, male and female
students obtained the same result in their averages. On the other hand, listening for meaning and
information are two components based on the listening comprehension skill. In these skills, our male
participants obtained 31,27% better than female students with 27,31%. However, these percentages do
not represent a high level of proficiency based on communication competencies and the Ecuadorian
curricular exit profile.
CONCLUSIONS
During the academic year 2023-2024, it was found that graduate students have a basic level of
communication skills. In particular, their oral communication skills need improvement. They lack
fluency in speaking, struggle with listening comprehension, do not practice oral production outside of
pág. 6952
the classroom, and have difficulty understanding specific details when listening. These issues may be a
result of the educational learning process, which could be explored further through future research. To
address these shortcomings, educators should provide more opportunities for students to improve their
oral communication skills within the classroom. Additionally, listening comprehension should be
encouraged by modeling good speaking habits. Developing communication skills requires significant
time and effort, both inside and outside the classroom. Therefore, it is essential to implement these
recommendations and establish performance criteria and indicators to ensure that learning objectives
and exit profiles are met. By doing so, students can achieve oral communication skills and become
effective communicators in both their professional and personal lives.
BIBLIOGRAPHY REFERENCE
Alahdal, A., & Al Ahdal, A. A. M. H. (2019). Effectiveness of collaborative learning as a strategy in
the teaching of EFL. Opción: Revista de Ciencias Humanas y Sociales, (20), 1026-1043.
Alcaráz-Mármol, G. (2019). Desarrollo de la competencia oral en inglés como lengua extranjera a través
de la mediación lingüística en educación secundaria. Elia, 19, 1540.
https://doi.org/10.12795/elia.2019.i19.02
Alvarez, C. M., & Guevara, P. C. M. (2021). EFL teachers’ perceptions on using pedagogical modules
in Ecuador: a focus group interview. Chakiñan, 14, 4256.
https://doi.org/10.37135/chk.002.14.03
Bernal, M., & Bernal, P. (2020). Using reading to teach English as a foreign language. Maskana, 11(2),
1826. https://doi.org/10.18537/mskn.11.02.02
Romero-Romero, L. A., De Los Ángeles Ormaza-Pincay, M., Naranjo-Flores, M. I., & Hernández-
Intriago, J. C. (2021). Influencia del inglés como segunda lengua en el currículo de la Carrera
de Bibliotecología en el Ecuador. Polo Del Conocimiento: Revista Científico - Profesional,
6(3), 4063. https://doi.org/10.23857/pc.v6i3.2351
Campbell, D. T., & Stanley, J. C. (2015). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research.
Ravenio books.
Crystal, D. (2003). English as a global language (Second edition ed.). Cambridge University Press.
pág. 6953
Guerrero-Quiñonez, A. J., Guagua, O. Q., & Barrera-Proaño, R. G. (2023). A look at university
education in Ecuador: politics, quality and teaching. Ibero-American Journal of Education &
Society Research, 3(1), 244248. https://doi.org/10.56183/iberoeds.v3i1.623
Guzmán Jordán, C. C., & Valle Gavilanes, D. del R. (2022). La educación inclusiva en Ecuador.
Identificación de características en docentes. ConcienciaDigital, 5(2), 69-87.
https://doi.org/10.33262/concienciadigital.v5i2.2131
Halim, A. . (2022). Curriculum Organization Development Process in Developing Education Indonesia.
Indonesian Journal of Education (INJOE), 2(2), 159169. Retrieved from
https://injoe.org/index.php/INJOE/article/view/21
Hallén, S. (2023). The Effectiveness of Visual Input for EFL Learners’ Vocabulary Acquisition.r, S.
Raza, M., & Seidman, E. (2019). Improving 21st-century teaching skills: The key to effective 21st-
century learners. Research in Comparative and International Education, 14(1), 99-117.
Krashen, S. (1982). Principles and practice in second language acquisition.
Llerena, C. L. Á., & Van Ha, X. (2022). Exploring English Language teaching in Ecuadorian Secondary
Schools: Teachers’ beliefs about the national curriculum reform. , 13(5), 1170.
https://doi.org/10.52547/lrr.13.5.5
Ministry of Education. (2016). English language curriculum. Ecuador. Retrieved from
https://educacion.gob.ec/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2016/08/EFL-for-Subnivel-BGU-
final-ok.pdf
Ministerio de Educación. (2016). Acuerdo Nro. MINEDUC-ME-2016-00020-A
Ministerio de Educación. (Enero - Diciembre de 2023). Rendición de Cuentas 2023. Obtenido de
Ministerio de Educación:
https://educacion.gob.ec/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2024/03/09D17.pdf
Reasco, J. N., & Rodríguez, M. P. (2022). Methodological Strategies to Strengthen Oral
Communication in the English Language.
Tawil, H. (2018). Task-Based and Situated Language Learning and Its Impact on Language Teaching.
International Journal of Language and Linguistics, 5 (4), 202 212.
pág. 6954
Van Zyl, H., Burger, Y., Carstens, L., & Geyser, M. (2020). Curriculum design as an enabler of student
involvement and success in higher education. South African Journal of Higher Education,
35(4). https://doi.org/10.20853/34-5-4267
Warschauer, M. (2005). Sociocultural perspectives on CALL. (J. Egbert, & G. Petrie, Eds.) CALL
Research Perspectives (pp. 41-51).
Yousef, R. (2023). The challenges that basic stage EFL students face in online listening comprehension
from their teachers' perspectives in Jordan. Technium Soc. Sci. J., 42, 15
Zarfsaz, E., & Takkac, M. (2014). Silence in foreign language learning: an analysis of students’ risk-
taking behavior in an EFL classroom. International Journal of Language Learning and Applied
Linguistics World, 6(3), 307-321.