WORK, ACCIDENTS AND ECONOMY IN THE
MINING SECTOR COLOMBIA VS MEXICO
ACCIDENTES DE TRABAJO Y ECONOMÍA EN EL
SECTOR MINERO COLOMBIA VS MÉXICO
Herminio Pabón Trujillo
Corporación Universitaria Minuto de Dios, Colombia
Diana Carolina Castilla Alvarez
Universidad de Pamplona, Colombia
Adriana Carolina Ramirez
Corporación Universitaria Minuto de Dios, Colombia
Teresa Isabel Peña
Corporación Universitaria Minuto de Dios, Colombia
Nelson Eduardo Rivera
Universidad de Pamplona, Colombia
pág. 7278
DOI: https://doi.org/10.37811/cl_rcm.v8i5.14140
Work Accidents and Economy in the Mining Sector Colombia vs Mexico
Herminio Pabón Trujillo
1
herminio.pabon.t@uniminuto.edu.co
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5636-4813
Corporación Universitaria
Minuto de Dios Colombia- Cúcuta
Diana Carolina Castilla Álvarez
Diana.castilla2@unipamplona.edu.co
https://orcid.org/0009-0003-3463-2911
Universidad de Pamplona
Colombia -Cúcuta
Adriana Carolina Ramírez
adriana.ramirez-ga@uniminuto.edu.com
https://orcid.org/0009-0005-3027-6045
Corporación Universitaria
Minuto De Dios Colombiana - Cúcuta
Teresa Isabel Peña
tpenacorred@uniminuto.edu.co
https://orcid.org/0009-0004-3004-7819
Corporación Universitaria
Minuto De Dios Colombiana Cúcuta
Nelson Eduardo Rivera
Nelson.rivera2@unipamplona.edu.co
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1969-6824
Universidad de Pamplona
Colombia- Cúcuta
ABSTRACT
The mining industry in Colombia is one of the main aspects of wealth in the country, which focuses on
the identification or discovery of mineral resources for use and exploitation, in addition the most
extracted minerals are gold, silver emeralds, platinum, copper, nickel and coal, we also have at the level
of Latin America the largest open-pit mine in the country, located in the guajira called the cerrejón,
while in Mexico is the largest open sky mine and is located in Cananea Sonora called Buena Vista,
where the main mineral of exploitation is copper there is also another very large and important mine for
Mexico as is the charity mine that can produce various minerals such as copper, molybdenum, gold and
silver. Objective Identify the causes of accidents in the mining industry in Mexico vs. Colombia in order
to create strategies that help mitigate the threats to which they are exposed. Methodology A documented
inquiry method was applied, which provided content published in thesis magazines, articles,
repositories, with the idea of identifying the most frequent accidents in this sector, because these tasks
have a high accident rate, with injuries that last several months and in the worst case, death Results
showed that in the last ten years, Colombia continues to increase the accident rate by 9.57 per hundred
workers, while in Mexico it has managed to reduce the accident rate in the mining sector by 75%, since
2010. to 2021.
Keywords: accidents, mining sector, safety, dangers
1
Autor principal
Correspondencia: herminio.pabon.t@uniminuto.edu.co
pág. 7279
Accidentes de Trabajo y Economía en el Sector Minero Colombia vs
México
RESUMEN
La industria minera en Colombia es una de las principales vertientes de riqueza del país, la cual se
enfoca en la identificación o descubrimiento de recursos minerales para su uso y explotación, además
los minerales más extraídos son oro, plata, esmeraldas, platino, cobre, níquel y carbón, también tenemos
a nivel de Latinoamérica la mina a cielo abierto más grande del país, ubicada en la guajira llamada el
cerrejón, mientras que en México está la mina a cielo abierto más grande y está ubicada en Cananea
Sonora llamada Buena Vista, donde el principal mineral de explotación es el cobre también existe otra
mina muy grande e importante para México como es la mina benéfica que puede producir diversos
minerales como cobre, molibdeno, oro y plata. Objetivo Identificar las causas de los accidentes en la
industria minera en México vs. Colombia con el fin de crear estrategias que ayuden a mitigar las
amenazas a las que están expuestos. Metodología Se aplicó un método de indagación documentada, que
aportó contenidos publicados en revistas de tesis, artículos, repositorios, con la idea de identificar los
accidentes más frecuentes en este sector, debido a que estas tareas tienen un alto índice de
accidentabilidad, con lesiones que duran varios meses y en el peor de los casos, la muerte. Los
resultados arrojaron que en los últimos diez años Colombia sigue incrementando la tasa de
accidentabilidad en un 9,57 por cada cien trabajadores, mientras que en México ha logrado reducir la
accidentabilidad en el sector minero en un 75%, desde 2010. 2021.
Palabras clave: accidentes, sector minero, seguridad, peligros
Artículo recibido 05 septiembre 2024
Aceptado para publicación: 10 octubre 2024
pág. 7280
INTRODUCTION
It is estimated that the mining sector in Colombia, as an increasingly growing activity in the raw
materials industry, both open pit and underground, has been having a strong impact on Work accidents,
according to the World Labor Organization (ILO), “although considerable.” “Attention is deployed in
Colombia.” , the rate of deaths, injuries and illnesses recorded among mining workers in recent years
remains high, and the mining occupation is the most dangerous, while Mexico analyzes the mining
sector as one of the jobs with the greatest exposure to any type of risk and accidents For this reason,
industrial safety has been strengthened to offer a safe work environment, since one of the reasons for
maintaining the low accident rate in recent years is the audit, supervision and creation of strategies, the
mining sector continues to monitor constantly to maintain security facilities and operations to continue
reducing work accidents, they also have the appropriate individual safety equipment for workers, and
thus improve quality and safety standards.
Colombia has a high accident rate of 1,262 employees with an average of 103 deaths each year in
Antioquia, Norte de Santander, Caldas, Cundinamarca and Boyacá, governed by the Ministry of Labor,
they are being more exhaustive in inspections, surveillance and control. as well as areas with a higher
accident rate, on the other hand, the Ministry of Economy (SE) of Mexico says that in the last ten years
170 workers have died and 108 have suffered injuries in mining work, departments such as Guanajuato,
Querétaro, Durango, Chihuahua, Coahuila, Zacatecas, San Luis Potosí, are part of the Sonora plant with
an accident rate.
Background
Hernández and Valencia, (2022) carry out research for a thesis with the title of “Effective management
of locative risks in the mining industry of Marmato Caldas” with the objective of designing strategies
to minimize locative risks in the mining sector, because In 2019, 92% were due to accidents in
underground mines and 5% in open pit mines, where 2,943 workers were involved in accidents and
occupational diseases from 2015 to 2019, It can also be observed that in 2019 the fatality mining was
1.5 percent and in 2020 it had an increase rate of 2.63 percent.
Bottura A. (2020) shows the importance of introducing technology and support equipment to reduce
accidents in the underground mining sector, so guaranteeing the protection of Mexican mining workers
pág. 7281
should be considered one of the most important objectives of the country, since 60% of accidents are
related to eminent dangers such as landslides and falling rocks, poor visibility, mechanical cutting and
drilling, electric arc, fire and explosion, demonstrating that 85% of workplace accidents are serious.
Calambas C. (2021) carries out a thesis with the title of “Behavior-Based Safety Management in the
Occurrence of Workplace Accidents in Underground Mining at the Quintana SAS Company” with the
purpose of designing strategies that help reduce workplace accidents, of this company because there
has been a high prevalence of accidents due to lack of training for personnel on the execution of tasks
for which they have been hired, every worker who joins a company must have a minimum induction
of eight hours as well Colombian regulations indicate this, as results were obtained that the company
Quintana S.A.S. They must make employees aware of the risks to which they are exposed in their
work area, as well as strengthen compliance with safe practices and self-care.
Fulze, L. (2021). carries out an investigation whose name is "Overconfidence causes the majority of
eventualities in the mining sector" with the purpose of building a control system and engineering
measures properly developed in the workplace, because the mining sector is one of the functions
considered the most dangerous, it is important that in the phases prior to the implementation of the
management system not only engineers and experts participate, it is recommended that all company
managers participate, if the contribution of the administrative part is active and committed, the success
of the program and the financial investments made by the company are guaranteed, many of the projects
fail due to the lack of real acceptance as well as the position of the organization before, during and after
the implementation of the plan.
Moncada L (2023) prepares a study on the main causes of accidents in underground coke mines, the
objective of knowing what causes accidents in the mining sector, since the majority of accidents occur
in workers between 18 and 25 years old who They do not have experience in carrying out the activities
and even less know how to assess the danger to which they are exposed, It is said that one of the main
reasons is the lack of real instructions when starting the activity, but also other reasons, such as
geomechanical failures, in which 33.1% of atmospheric fluctuations represent 19% and the main cause
is an explosion, with 13.2 being a probability factor for a major accident.
pág. 7282
According to previous studies, it is possible to collect information from people, magazines, articles and
documents where they have carried out research on the mining sector of Colombia vs Mexico, In this
documentary review we were able to demonstrate the importance of the management system in these
companies, because A comparison of the accident rate was carried out between these two countries
where Colombia stands out with the highest prevalence of accidents in this sector due to the need for
rigorous implementation of the management system, risk assessment, violation of safety procedures as
well as training on the dangers that are exposed in the work area, while in Mexico today the mining
industry has managed to make safety one of its most important values and policies, promoting a
sustainable culture of prevention and significantly reducing accidents, in addition By 2022 the accident
rate was 0.90 percent per 100 employees.
METHODOLOGY
A documented inquiry method was applied, which provided content published in thesis journals,
articles, repositories, with the idea of identifying the most frequent accidents in this sector, because
these tasks have a high accident rate, with injuries that last several months and in the worst case, the
death.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
For this study, a bibliographic search was carried out through online portals; Among the materials, for
example, it was based on data from the mining committee, articles, the mining chamber of Mexico
(Camimex), archives or university repositories where accidents are investigated in the Colombian
mining industry as well as in Mexico, it should be noted that According to the world organization of
labor (ILO), the relevant common causes of occupational accidents in this sector are explosions,
chemical substances, noise, vibrations, heat, humidity, overexertion, reduced environment, inadequate
utensils, collapses and rockfalls, it is worth pointing out that merchants and mining workers are unaware
of the health consequences of improper use of personal protective equipment, but it must be understood
that these do not eliminate the problem, but they do reduce the probability of contracting an occupational
disease.
Likewise, with the investigation, it is possible to demonstrate the working conditions in the underground
mines of Mexico that have a great difference from Colombia, because in this country they invest in
pág. 7283
work hygiene seeking comfort and tranquility, which has as a response the reduction of the index,
accident rate for collaborators, creating prevention strategies and innovation of processes and training.
In the same way, they make a selection of ideal personnel for the position to work, they also implement
a mining shelter that is installed in the highest part of the mine that has with air conditioning, oxygen
cylinders, measuring equipment, radio communicated to the surface, food, hydration, and bathroom,
these companies in Mexico have been characterized as leaders in generating secure employment, since
by 2022 the mining chamber of Mexico (Camimex) silver helmet award to companies with best safe
practices and lowest accident rate in the mining sector who ensure they continue investing in
occupational safety and hygiene to reach zero accidents.
Although Colombia has stood out as a country with the highest number of accidents in the mining
sector, due to safety conditions, little investment in the management system, non-compliance with
standards, lack of regulations, one of the biggest failures of the safety system. . , the current policy is
the lack of a work plan that facilitates the supervision of planned actions and also shows the number of
accidents in the industry, which is part of the initiatives promoted by the Ministry of Labor,
strengthening control, monitoring and supervision, visiting the sectors with the highest number of
accidents, especially in departments such as Norte de Santander, Antioquia, Boyacá, Caldas and
Cundinamarca. , dedicated to the mining industry, guaranteeing compliance with labor standards and
mitigating accidents, we also continue to promote a safe work environment and promote promotion and
prevention instruction aimed at improving the quality of life where workers are trained in management
and hazard recognition.
Figure 1
Ramirez A. (2024) Collaborative work Coil.
47%
34%
19%
2020
2021
2022
Accident Rate in the Mining Sector of Mexico Year
2020 to 2022
pág. 7284
In the mining industry in Mexico in the last three years statistics show that the accident rate has been
reduced by up to 64% for the year 2020, the accident rate was 11% of workers while in 2021 there was
an increase of 15% by 2022 there is a 10% decrease in accidents so far this year.
Figure 2
Ramirez A. (2024) Collaborative work Coil.
It is possible to analyze in the statistics that Colombia in the mining industry sector in the last year has
been increasing worryingly compared to previous years, as can be seen in the graph in 2020 the accident
rate was 21% followed by 2021 with 33% and ending the year 2022 with an index of 37%.
Figure 3
Ramirez A. (2024) Collaborative work Coil.
There are many causes that cause accidents in the mining area in Mexico, some of them minor that lead
to disabilities and others such as death, we found that one of the main sources of accidents are explosions
with 49% compared to 26% of landslides and 25% of rockfalls.
25%
26%
49%
Caidas de Rocas
Desboramiento
Explosion
Causas De Accidentalidad En La Idustria Minera De
Mexico En Los Ultimos diez años
21%
33%
37%
2020
2021
2022
Accident Rate in the Mining Sector of Colombia Year
2020 to 2022
pág. 7285
Figure 4
Ramirez A. (2024) Collaborative work Coil.
In the graph we were able to show that in Colombia one of the main factors of accidents are explosions
with a record of 60% along with the vitiated atmosphere with 22% followed by collapses with 18%.
CONCLUSIONS
It is possible to conclude from the study of the Colombian mining industry that it still needs to
strengthen safety and hygiene at work, due to the high accident rate, as well as put into operation
individual safety equipment, formation or training on the use and manipulation of work tools Similarly,
on the other hand, the country of Mexico shows us that they constantly work on the continuous
improvement of occupational health to also guarantee the well-being and safety at work of their
collaborators.
The comparison between these countries in occupational safety and hygiene shows the great difference
that Mexico has more efficient occupational safety and where they make the necessary investments to
reduce accidents and provide the best guarantees of safe work, while Colombia continues to work on it,
but even so it continues to be one of the countries with the highest number of accidents.
Finally, with this research on the mining sector of these countries we were able to see the discrepancy
that exists in managing safety, health and hygiene at work properly, the benefits that come with making
the necessary investments for this work area that is among one of the increasingly dangerous jobs, and
there is also a reduction in job insolvency, professional absenteeism and its greatest effect, accidents.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
pág. 7286
Rodríguez, ER, Reyes Chanagá , E., & Torres Vela, YM (2020). Technical analysis of occupational
health and safety management systems for the underground mining sector in the Municipality
of Muzo, Department of Boyacá-Colombia.
Avendaño, Y., Goyeneche, J., Herrera, Y. & Venegas, E. (2023). Generation of strategies to reduce
disabilities and/or absenteeism caused by work accidents in the mining sector (coal extraction)
in the department of Boyacá. ( Monograph ). Corporation Minuto de Dios University , Bogotá
Colombia.
Salinas Usma, WD (2022). Identification of the behavior of workers in the mining sector regarding the
risk factors that cause accidents and occupational diseases. [Graduate work, Minuto de Dios
University Corporation]. UNIMINUTO institutional repository.
Sepúlveda, DY, García Hernández, V. and Ballesteros Upegui, LM (2021). Accident in the sinkhole
due to unsafe acts in Minera La Subasta SAS company during the first semester of 2021.
[Degree work, Minuto de Dios University Corporation]. UNIMINUTO institutional repository.
Ramos Hernandez , JA, & Valencia Rios, OY (2022). Effective management of lease risk in the mining
sector in Marmato Caldas.
Hernández Arango, LL (2021). Analysis of the general system of occupational risks in the mining and
quarrying sector in the department of Antioquia. Period 2010 to 2020.
Calambas Barrera, CI (2021). Safety management based on behavior in the occurrence of work
accidents in underground mining in the Quintana SAS company.
Cubillos Morales, DM (2023). Occupational diseases in small-scale mining companies in Colombia: an
analysis of the challenges and opportunities for the prevention and protection of mining
workers.
MORA CRUZ, GERALDINE (2023). Current state of Mining in Colombia and the identification of
impacts.
Vera Jimenez , AD, & Vera Marín, MA (2023). Population characterization, risks and workplace
accidents in the mining areas of Salado and Pache of the Municipal GAD of Portovelo
(Doctoral dissertation , University of Guayaquil. Faculty of Industrial Engineering . Industrial
Engineering Degree .).
pág. 7287
Callupe Baldeon , L. (2023). Safety based on behavior and reduction of work accidents in a mining
company, Lima, 2022.
Bardales Canales, JD, & Alcantara Mendez , L.M. (2024). Design of an occupational health and safety
management system to reduce occupational risks in a mining contractor, Cajamarca 2022.
Gaibor Moreta, SS (2023). Preparation of a proposal to improve the management of occupational safety
and health of the mining company “El Guasmoin the San Miguel canton of the province of
Bolívar.
Hernández Rivera, GP, & Jiménez Patiño, JL (2023). Evolution of regulations related to occupational
diseases in Colombia ( Bachelor's thesis).
Pomatay Paquiyauri , A. (2023). Influence of the occupational health and safety management system
on the reduction of occupational risks in the mining company Los Andes Construction and
Services SAC Compañía Minera Alpayana SAA.
Inche Soto, W. (2023). Evaluation of security standards for the adaptation of ISO 45001 in the security
system of Compañía Minera Lincuna SA.
Avendaño Báez, YP, Goyeneche Moreno, JE, Herrera Molano, YK, & Venegas Molina, E. (2023).
Generation of strategies to reduce disabilities and/or absenteeism caused by work accidents in
the mining sector (coal extraction) in the department of Boyacá (Doctoral thesis, Minuto de
Dios University Corporation).
Fulze, L. (2021, September 26). 90% of accidents in the mining industry are caused by overconfidence
. Safe start. https://la.safestart.com/90-de-accidentes-en-la-industria-minera-son-provocados-
por-el-exceso-de-confianza/
Global Energy. (2020, October 30). Risks of the mining sector in Mexico . Global Energy.
https://globalenergy.mx/noticias-especiales/columnas/riesgos-del-sector-minero-en-mexico/
Valencia Martínez, A. (2023). Historical-scientific actors and organizational systems as agents in the
construction of knowledge in mining in Mexico, (1792-2019): towards a sustainable practice.
Téllez Ramírez, I., & Sánchez Salazar, MT (2022). Mining employment in Mexico: current situation
and trends.
pág. 7288
Adrián, BBS, Alexandra, CN, & Giovanni, GAH (2020). Strategy to minimize work accidents in
underground work of a mining company.